DRUMMERS

NEWS/EVENTS

MULTIMEDIA

EDUCATION

FORUM

SHOP

BOOKS

 PHOTO GALLERY

CONTESTS

CONTACT

BACK ISSUES

SUBSCRIBER
SERVICES












View Critiques from our Archives Select from Modern Drummer's Critique Archive

CAB
CAB4
Dennis Chambers
Media Type: CD
RATING: 10




This is the best instrumental fusion release in many moons. Tony MacAlpine (guitar), Bunny Brunel (bass), Brian Auger, Patrice Rushen (keys), and the unrestrained DENNIS CHAMBERS are at the top of their game, playing with a fire that rekindles the passionate musicianship and technically and melodically interesting compositions of the early-?70s fusion pioneers. Chambers? over-the-top drumming is inspiring from beginning to end. This is what great jazz-rock fusion is all about.
Mike Haid

California Guitar Trio
California Guitar Trio with Tony Levin and Pat Mastelotto
Pat Mastelotto
Media Type: CD
RATING: 7




California Guitar Trio navigate umpteen textures and styles here, giving PAT MASTELOTTO plenty of room to kick up his multi-talented arsenal. Mastelotto?s full-frontal tom assault on Yes?s "Heart Of The Sunrise" is a pure rhythmic earthquake, and his solo in Mahavishnu Orchestra?s "Dance Of Maya" is downright brutal. But he shines throughout the album in subtle, surprising ways. This is an excellent showcase for Mastelotto, but any drummer would love to groove over CGT's expansive styles and intricate arrangements.

Carl Palmer
Do Ya Wanna Play, Carl? and Working Live, Vol. One
Carl Palmer
Media Type: CD
RATING: 6




Fans of classical rock trio ELP?s innovative and dominant Carl Palmer now have the opportunity to relive the drummer?s shining moments. Disc one of Do Ya Wanna Play, Carl? highlights ELP pieces that featured Palmer's fluid rudimental chops and blazing speed. Disc two rewinds to a fifteen-year-old Palmer?s Keith Moon-ish flailing with The Craig, tracks from Atomic Rooster, ?80s super-group Asia, Mike Oldfield, 3, Palmer?s PM, Qango, and even The Buddy Rich Orchestra. On Working Live, Volume One, Palmer proves he still has the fire. Here, Palmer?s current power trio with Shaun Baxter (guitar) and Dave Marks (bass) performs the music of ELP, and Carl sounds truly energized, with his strongest groove playing to date. The disc closes with an impressive six-plus-minute drum solo. Recommended. (www.carlpalmer.com)
Mike Haid

Cathedral
The VIIth Coming
Brian Dixon
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Cathedral The VIIth Coming Brian Dixon

After inflicting serious torture on his own vocal chords in Napalm Death, singer Lee Dorrian assembled a more melodic, Sabbath-inspired unit. Cathedral's tuneful doom-metal continues to glow bright on their seventh full-length. And Sharon Osbourne would probably get the warm fuzzies over Dorrian's vocals on this platter, while Bill Ward would likely approve of BRIAN DIXON's big, brawny chops. But notice all the clever and sometimes subtle intricacies in Dixon's drumming on the semi-acoustic, prog-rock-powered "Aphrodite's Winter" and the stage-stomping "Empty Mirror." (Dig that cowbell!)

Jeff Perlah

Charged Particles
Sparks
Jon Krosnick
Media Type: CD
RATING: 7


Charged Particles Sparks Jon Krosnick

From the subtle pulse of "Peladon" to the offbeat drive of "Eleventh Commandment," JON KROSNICK's drumming for Charged Particles is an integral part of this group's sound. A solid jazz fusion album with some Latin and light funk tinges, memorable tunes give the group room to play.

Martin Patmos

Charles Lloyd
Hyperion With Higgins
Billy Higgins (dr, perc)
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Charles Lloyd Hyperion With Higgins Billy Higgins (dr, perc)

Recorded a few months before Higgins' death, Hyperion is culled from the same sessions as this quintet's previous The Water Is Wide. More energized than Water's tracks, these cuts share Lloyd's signature spiritual boil. From straight swinging to wide-open improv, it's an incredibly warm-toned, connected fellowship. And master Higgins is once again magic. He leads the dance with elegance and understatement. His incredible touch, melodic sense, and surging swing could only come from a great at peak maturity. (ECM)

Jeff Potter

Charlie Hunter Quintet
Right Now Move
Derek Phillips
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Charlie Hunter Quintet Right Now Move Derek Phillips

A quick glance at Charlie Hunter shows a man with a guitar. Then why are you hearing a bass and a Hammond organ? Well, that's just his thang -- to simultaneously coax a stunning variety of tones and rhythms from his custom eight-string. Hunter's new band, which includes horns and harmonica, specializes in funk and Latin grooves. DEREK PHILLIPS plays impeccably, with a deep pocket and a spirited sense of joy. Supportive yet exciting in his own right, he deftly handles whatever's thrown at him: His funk hits the spot, his shuffle percolates, and he whips up a mean songo.

Michael Parillo

Charlie Watts And The Tentet
Watts At Scott's
Charlie Watts
Media Type: CD
RATING: 6


Charlie Watts And The Tentet Watts At Scott's Charlie Watts Blistering bop, big band?like assaults, chamber-style passages?this double-disc live set from 2001 runs the gamut of Rolling Stone drummer Charlie Watts? ?other? career. As The Tentet blows through originals and covers of Monk, Miles, Ellington, and The Stones, Watts? ride cymbal blankets the foreground like gentle rain, as percussionist LUIS JARDIM expels the rhythmic equivalent of thunderclaps. Nine minutes in, the sixteen-minute standout track, ?Elvin?s Song,? explodes with exciting African polyrhythms. There?s nary a trace of Elvin?s style in it, but Watts? relaxed and natural feel is far more rewarding than copped chops could ever be.
Will Romano

Chick Corea
Rendezvous In New York
Haynes, Ballard, Weckl, and Gadd
Media Type: CD
RATING: 9


Chick Corea Rendezvous In New York Haynes, Ballard, Weckl, and Gadd

Who else but Chick Corea could pull off a three-week-long 60th birthday celebration at New York City's Blue Note and invite a virtual who's who of jazz-musician friends from past and present collaborations? This two-disc set is chock-full of outstanding performances from former Corea drummers including ROY HAYNES, JEFF BALLARD, DAVE WECKL, and STEVE GADD, performing selections from each of their past projects with Corea. This is a rare opportunity to hear a spirited Akoustic Band reunion (Weckl), as well as the legendary Gadd swinging hard with Corea and Michael Brecker performing the classic Three Quartets Band material.

Mike Haid

Chick Corea Elektric Band
To The Stars
Dave Weckl
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Chick Corea Elektric Band To The Stars Dave Weckl Legendary keyboardist/composer Chick Corea reunites the stellar crew of the original Elektric Band for a celestial return to planet Fusion. On To The Stars, Corea explores Latin, Afro-Cuban, African, and jazz-rock instrumental compositions based on characters and places from the L. Ron Hubbard sci-fi novel of the same name. Veteran rhythmic pioneer DAVE WECKL energizes the partially complex, partially groove-oriented material with a mature, relaxed feel, illustrating his extraordinary ability to creatively orchestrate melodies within a rhythmically advanced framework. This group of gifted explorers is still light years ahead in the scientific musical universe.
Mike Haid

Chimaira
The Impossibility Of Reason
Andols Herrick
Media Type: CD
RATING: 7


Chimaira The Impossibility Of Reason Andols Herrick

As its mythical name implies, this Cleveland sextet is a raging beast, blending monstrous extreme metal with various melodic stylings. The aural chaos on this, their third album, is expertly held together by ANDOLS HERRICK's drumming. Herrick takes the spotlight on occasion, as his tribal toms prove on the Soulfly-like "Pure Hatred." Following the eerie sound effects and military-style drum roll of opener "Cleansation," Herrick's speedy footwork and crisp command of his kit give Mark Hunter's madman vocals something to chomp on. Sometimes, Chimaira harks back to the days of long, bluesy guitar solos. But Reason ultimately sounds fresh.

Jeff Perlah

Chris Lacinak
Boom
Chris Lacinak
Media Type: CD
RATING: 6


Chris Lacinak Boom Chris Lacinak

A notable in-demand New Orleans jazz drummer, CHRIS LACINAK wielded his talents in New York during the past decade, freelancing and passing the torch as a teacher at the Drummers Collective. Now returned to his musical homeland, Lacinak embraces his roots on Boom, aided by top local sidemen. The sessions have a loose, jammy feel, complementing the drummer's irresistibly snaky, breathing grooves. The acoustic quintet mixes rootsy second-line inflections with swing and unchained soloing. Lacinak's commanding drumming leads the collective improv with a spontaneity and spirit that says, "Ain't it nice to be home again!" (www.cdfreedom.com)

Jeff Potter

Christiansen
Stylish Nihilists
Terry Campbell
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Christiansen Stylish Nihilists Terry Campbell Just a few measures into the roaring album opener, ?Kentucky Goddamn,? and you?ll instantly bear witness to punk percussionist TERRY CAMPBELL?s masterful stickwork. The impenetrable drummer is all over the map on Christiansen?s latest, furiously shifting gears between laying concrete passages (like the Taylor Hawkins-esque kick/snare patterns of ?Under Things Killed?), providing subtle yet defined accented kicks (feel the mellow, Rush groove of ?Cocaine Summer?), or waging all-out war on the kit, found in brief spurts throughout Stylish Nihilists. File it right next to genre greats At The Drive-In and Burning Airlines, but yank it out often, particularly for those spirited air-drumming sessions.
Waleed Rashidi

Chrome Yellow
itswhatsnext
Warpath (dr)
Media Type: CD
RATING: 7


Chrome Yellow itswhatsnext Warpath Modern rock with a good dose of '70s-flavored funky soul and a taste of Texas blues is what Florida's up-and-coming Chrome Yellow is all about. A solid album, these tracks are littered with Warpath's crisp, syncopated snare and elaborate hi-hat playing. Throughout the album, the drummer's laid-back yet grounded groove sets up the rest of the band. (www.itswhatsnext.com)

Cindy Blackman
Someday...
Cindy Blackman (dr)
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Cindy Blackman Someday... Cindy Blackman

From the opening strains of "My Funny Valentine," Cindy Blackman's surging pulse once again demands attention as she accents and prods the tune along. Throughout this album, the follow-up to her brilliant Works On Canvas, Blackman lays down a rhythmic cushion to support her group. Blackman is an exciting drummer, with her fantastic sense of swing and syncopated juggling. And using Tony Williams' work with Miles Davis as a starting point, her group has created another solid album. (HighNote)

Clinic
Walking With Thee

Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Clinic Walking With Thee

Clinic spins on an atomic sonic carousel that would make most bands explode. On Walking With Thee slices of such diverse genres as punk, psychedelia, frosty electronica, and violent garage rock come together to create an amusing, sick-phonic Frankenstein. The band also seems to be running on its own intangible meter. CARL TURNEY?s big, lusty beats are merely one ingredient driving the pulsating rhythms. (Domino)
Will Romano

Clyde Stubblefield
The Original
Clyde Stubblefield
Media Type: CD
RATING: 6


Clyde Stubblefield The Original Clyde Stubblefield The groove that made James Brown famous returns on CLYDE STUBBLEFIELD?s debut. If ever a groove contained magic, it?s Stubblefield?s?from the jaunty New Orleans funk of "The Difference" and the shuffle of "The Walking Band" to the popping snare punches of "Hippest March." Stubblefield?s tipping pocket and righteous groove remain unchanged by time, each performance here a lesson in rhythmic assurance. He even smokes fusion-funk on "Okay," a tongue-tying groove that nearly suspends time. If you can get past the questionable vocals, tooting saxophone, and production gimmicks, you?ll find Clyde?s drumming as potent as ever.
Ken Micallef

Concrete Blonde
Group Therapy

Media Type: CD
RATING: 5




Concrete Blonde?s reunited original lineup serves up some quirky tunes for the real draw here?Johnette Napolitano?s signature voice. James A. Mankey?s aggressive, atmospheric guitars are a highlight, and HARRY RUSHAKOFF?s boxy drumming is solid, if not particularly exciting. By not reacting to the passion of the others, he misses ample opportunity for drama. (Manifesto)
Linda Pitmon

Converge
Jane Doe
Ben Koller (dr)
Media Type: CD
RATING: 7


Converge Jane Doe Ben Koller

An examination of Converge's musical core reveals strong neo-punk-metal songcraft beneath the screaming guitars and relentlessly pounding drums. There's also a welcome balance between dizzying odd-metered sections and good ol'-fashioned 2 & 4 bashing. Drummer Ben Koller specializes in furious single-stroke rolls that start on the snare and growl their way around deepening tom-toms. He's equally at home with over-the-top metal orchestration and stripped-down punk aggression. ( www.equalvision.com )

Cooper Temple Clause, The
Kick Up The Fire, And Let The Flames Break Loose
Jon Harper
Media Type: CD
RATING: 6


Cooper Temple Clause, The Kick Up The Fire, And Let The Flames Break Loose Jon Harper A veritable smorgasbord of percussive rock rhythms, patterns, tones?and best of all, ideas?The Cooper Temple Clause?s RCA debut finds JON HARPER to be quite a busy man behind the kit. Harper?s responsible for generating a wide array of material?and then trying to make it all fit. There?s some cool programming to be found in the act?s repertoire, but Harper?s best when slamming away ("A.I.M.") or in step with tightly riffed guitar rhythms ("Promises, Promises"). Sonically referencing everything from Nirvana and Radiohead to The Jesus And Mary Chain and The Cure, it?s an overwhelming presentation, better appreciated in small doses.
Waleed Rashidi

Coral
The Coral
Ian Skelly
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Coral The Coral Ian Skelly

It?s one thing crossing acid-rock Klezmer with funky bossa nova, sea shanties, and reggae, but England?s Coral do it in head-spinningly good songs. Drummer IAN SKELLY rides over their Captain Beefheart/Yardbirds merriment with agile technique and soulful interpretive flair. When the band rages on "I Remember When," he plays it simple. But when the hidden track appears, Skelly finds Latin figures and a fat Ringo groove. This drummer always plays for the song, but The Coral?s traffic-jam approach allows for equal parts Levon Helm and Bill Bruford. Skelly plays the dual roles with style.
Ken Micallef

Crime In Choir
The Hoop
Jay Pellici
Media Type: CD
RATING: 6


Crime In Choir The Hoop Jay Pellici Crime In Choir are clearly unafraid of the term ?prog rock??in fact, my guess is either Dad or big bro played a lot of Camel and Soft Machine records back in the day. There?s also a bit of Air and Trans Am in the mix, which makes The Hoop a fine musical dish indeed?classic genre-bending, with a decidedly modern sense of urgency. Drummer JAY PELLICI mercifully steers clear of academic politeness, instead wailing on sloshy hi-hats, pushing the time?basically he gets his fingernails dirty. It might be progressive, but ultimately it?s rock.
Adam Budofsky

Cryptopsy
None So Live: Montreal 2002
Flo Mounier
Media Type: CD
RATING: 8


Cryptopsy None So Live: Montreal 2002 Flo Mounier

Most extreme-metal live albums sound as if they were recorded on a cruddy microcassette machine. Yet Cryptopsy?s pulverizing presentation comes across loud and clear here, while the quintet perform in a tight and dynamic way. So feast your ears on the drumming of FLO MOUNIER, whose whirlwind style is arguably the most essential aspect of this Montreal band?s unpredictable death-metal/grindcore. Mounier plays like he?s got eight limbs. But rather than sounding too chaotic (the metal/grindcore drummer?s curse), his signature changes and various complexities are usually artful and in control. Extreme-metal drumming at its finest.
Jeff Perlah









 Search for Another Critique in our Archives

A

 

B

 

C

 

D

 

E

 

F

 

G

 

H

 

I

 

J

 

K

 

L

 

M

 

N

 

O

 

P

 

Q

 

R

 

S

 

T

 

U

 

V

 

W

 

X

 

Y

 

Z


Modern Drummer Magazine © 2010
Privacy Policy